Walk into The Tile Shop expecting big-box pricing and you will leave disappointed. Walk in expecting a curated showroom with help from people who actually know what dot mounted means, and the experience is closer to high-end. The Tile Shop reviews from real homeowners and contractors paint a consistent picture: solid product, knowledgeable staff, and prices that sit between Home Depot and a designer showroom. After buying material from them for two kitchen remodels and a master bath, here is the honest take on what they do well and where they fall short.
The Company at a Glance
The Tile Shop is a US specialty retailer with around 140 locations across 31 states, headquartered in Plymouth, Minnesota. Founded in 1985, they focus on natural stone, glass, and porcelain tile rather than the broad surface-and-flooring catalog of Floor and Decor or the home center mass-market mix at Home Depot and Lowe’s.
Each store operates as a small showroom with full-size sample boards, design consultants on the floor, and a stockroom configured for both DIY and contractor pickup.
Product Selection
This is where The Tile Shop genuinely earns its premium pricing. The catalog skews heavily toward:
- Natural marble — Carrara, Calacatta, Bianco Dolomiti, slate, travertine
- Hand-painted Spanish and Portuguese cement tiles
- Glass mosaics in dozens of colorways and shapes
- Designer porcelain — wood-look, large-format, encaustic patterns
- Specialty trims — pencil liners, bullnose, listellos, decorative borders
The Tile Shop reviews consistently call out the quality of their natural stone selection. Calibration on marble and travertine is tight — sheet edges line up cleanly, thickness is consistent, and color matching across a single dye lot holds up better than what you typically get at big-box.
Real Pros
Staff knowledge is the standout. Most locations have at least one employee who can talk through grout joint width, thinset selection (modified vs unmodified for porcelain over uncoupling membrane, for example), and trim profile selection. Compare that to a Saturday morning at Home Depot where you may wait 20 minutes for someone to find the lippage system aisle.
Sample policy is generous. Most stores let you take home full-size samples for 30 days at no charge. That is essential for marble and natural stone where lighting and surrounding finishes radically change appearance.
Stock depth on certain SKUs is excellent. Common sizes (12×24 porcelain, 3×6 subway, 1×1 hex mosaic) ship same day from local store stock. Specialty product runs 1-3 weeks from regional warehouse.
The Honest Cons
Pricing runs 25-50 percent above Floor and Decor for comparable product. A 12×24 porcelain that lists for $2.99/sq ft at Floor and Decor often runs $4.50-5.99 at The Tile Shop. The product is sometimes legitimately better; sometimes it is the same factory in the same Italian region, just a different SKU.
Sales pressure is real at some locations. Several recent reviews describe push to upsell trims, spacers, sealers, and additional services after the initial tile selection is made. Know your project list before you walk in.
Returns can be friction-heavy. Cut tile, opened boxes, and even untouched but dye-lot-matched stock sometimes hit restocking fees of 10-25 percent. Read the receipt return policy at your specific store before buying volume.
How They Compare to Competitors
Versus Floor and Decor: The Tile Shop has more curated selection, better trims, and slightly better staff knowledge. Floor and Decor has dramatically broader inventory, lower prices, and bigger contractor accounts. For a budget-conscious DIY job, Floor and Decor wins. For a tightly designed kitchen with high-end natural stone, The Tile Shop usually wins.
Versus Home Depot and Lowe’s: The Tile Shop is in another league on selection quality and staff knowledge but charges 30-60 percent more. For basic field tile in straightforward sizes, Home Depot and Lowe’s are fine. For pattern tile, calibrated marble, or specialty trims, the big-box selection runs out fast.
Versus designer showrooms (Ann Sacks, Walker Zanger): The Tile Shop is significantly cheaper but with proportionally less designer credibility. For magazine-grade kitchens specifying named collections, the showrooms still win.
Installation and Pro Services
The Tile Shop offers in-store installation referrals and, in select markets, a full installation service. Reviews on the install side are mixed — some markets have excellent crews who deliver clean work, others rely on subcontractors with variable skill.
If you are buying material and finding your own installer, ask for the lot numbers on the invoice and verify all boxes match before install starts. Cross-lot mixing on natural stone produces visible color banding that no installer can fix.
What Recent Customer Reviews Say
Across 2024-2026 review aggregators (Yelp, Google, BBB, Reddit), the consistent themes are:
- Positive: showroom presentation, designer help, natural stone quality
- Mixed: install service quality varies widely by market
- Negative: pricing premium, sales pressure, restocking on returns
- Watch-outs: lot variation on long-lead-time orders, delivery timing slips
Tips for Getting the Best Outcome
Walk in with a measured drawing, a budget range, and a Pinterest board. Stores work best when staff has constraints to design within. Ask for full-size samples in your home lighting before ordering volume. Verify lot numbers on every box at pickup. Order 12-15 percent overage on natural stone, 8-10 percent on porcelain.
For installation, get three quotes including The Tile Shop’s referral. If the in-store quote is 30+ percent above the others, take an outside contractor.
Bottom Line
The Tile Shop reviews shake out to the same conclusion most experienced remodelers reach: it is a premium specialty retailer with genuine selection and staff advantages over big-box, but you pay for it. For a tightly designed kitchen, master bath, or fireplace where natural stone and trim selection matters, the upcharge is worth it. For straightforward field tile on a tight budget, Floor and Decor or Home Depot will get you 90 percent of the look at 60-70 percent of the cost.
Prefer to explore on your own?
See how new flooring looks in your actual room in seconds — free, no signup.
Try the free Floor Studio →
