Home Improvement

Shutter Colors for Brick Houses by Brick Tone

Shutter Colors for Brick Houses by Brick Tone

Brick is the one exterior color you cannot change cheaply, so the right shutter colors for brick houses start with reading the brick, not with a favorite paint chip. A red brick with blue-gray mortar wants a different shutter than a sandy orange brick or a chocolate-brown one, and painted white brick opens up almost every option. Match the shutter to the brick’s undertone, then let the trim and front door finish the scheme.

Most brick has a dominant body color plus flecks, flashing and mortar that shift the overall read. Stand at the curb in daylight, squint, and note whether the facade reads warm (orange, rust, tan) or cool (blue-red, purple-red, gray-brown). That single observation narrows the list faster than anything else.

Shutter Colors for Brick Houses: Pairing Table by Brick Tone

The pairings here are starting points that tend to look right from the street. Each one works with white or off-white trim unless noted.

Brick tone Classic shutter choices Bolder options Usually avoid
Traditional red Black, deep green, charcoal Navy, slate blue Bright red, orange-based browns
Blue-red or purple-red Black, charcoal, dark gray-green Deep plum, gray-blue Warm tan, mustard
Orange or rust Dark bronze, black-brown, deep olive Muted teal, warm charcoal Cool icy blue, bright white shutters
Brown or chocolate Cream, black, dark bronze Sage green, warm taupe Medium brown that matches the brick
Tan, buff or sandy Dark brown, forest green, black Muted blue, burgundy Beige close to the brick
Multicolor or flashed Black, charcoal, color pulled from the darkest brick Deep green pulled from mortar or roof Any mid-tone that fights the mix
Painted white brick Black, navy, charcoal Deep green, blue-gray, natural wood Pastels that wash out
Gray or whitewashed brick Black, charcoal, slate Navy, muted green Warm brown that looks muddy

A useful rule: shutters should be clearly darker or clearly lighter than the brick. A shutter that lands at the same depth as the masonry visually disappears and makes the windows look smaller.

Shutters for Red Brick House Exteriors

Red brick is the most common case, and it is also the most forgiving. Black shutters are the safe classic because they read as a crisp outline against any red. Deep hunter or forest green is the historic pairing on Colonial and Georgian homes, and it softens the contrast slightly. Navy or slate blue works when the brick has cooler purple or gray flashing; on a warm orange-red, blue can look jarring.

Check the roof too. A black or charcoal roof ties naturally to black or charcoal shutters, while a brown or weathered-wood roof leans toward dark bronze or green. If you want something different from the neighbors, a very dark green-black or a soft black with a hint of blue gives depth without breaking the traditional look.

Orange, Rust and Tan Brick

Warm, orange-leaning brick is common on ranch homes from the 1960s and 1970s, and it can look dated with the wrong shutter. Cool, bright colors fight the orange. Instead, pick shutters with warm depth: dark bronze, black-brown, deep olive, or a warm charcoal. These anchor the brick and make the orange read richer, closer to terracotta.

For tan or buff brick, contrast is easier because the brick is light. Dark brown, black and forest green all work. A muted blue or burgundy can be striking if the trim stays a soft cream rather than stark white.

Brown Shutters on Brick House Exteriors

Brown shutters on brick can look excellent or invisible, and the difference is contrast. On red or tan brick, a very dark espresso or bronze brown gives a warm, quiet frame. On medium brown brick, a matching mid-brown shutter vanishes, so go much darker (near-black brown) or switch to cream, which looks tailored on chocolate brick. Sage green is a softer alternative on brown brick that suits craftsman and cottage styles.

Painted White and Gray Brick

Painted or limewashed brick removes the undertone problem, so the shutter carries the personality of the house. Black is the modern farmhouse default. Navy and deep green read traditional, while charcoal feels contemporary. Natural or stained wood shutters warm up a white brick facade and work well with black window frames.

Gray or whitewashed brick with some red showing through behaves like a cool brick. Stick with black, charcoal, slate or navy, and avoid warm browns that can make the mix look muddy.

Looking to buy Shutter Colors for Brick Houses by Brick Tone? Compare top-rated options.
Shop on Amazon →Browse Our Shop
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Brick Houses With Shutters: Trim, Door and Roof Coordination

Brick houses with shutters look best when the scheme follows a three-color plan: brick as the main field, a trim color for fascia, soffits and window casings, and an accent for shutters and the front door. A few combinations that hold up well:

  • Red brick, white trim, black shutters, red or black door: crisp and traditional.
  • Red brick, cream trim, deep green shutters, natural wood door: softer, historic.
  • Orange brick, warm white trim, dark bronze shutters, deep teal door: updates a dated ranch.
  • Brown brick, cream trim, cream shutters, black door: tailored and calm.
  • Painted white brick, black windows, black shutters, natural wood door: modern farmhouse.

The front door can match the shutters for a uniform look, or it can be the one bolder color. Keep it to one standout so the facade does not look busy.

How to Test Shutter Colors Before Painting

  1. Narrow to three candidates from the pairing table based on your brick tone.
  2. Buy sample sizes and paint each on a large poster board or scrap panel, at least 2 by 3 feet.
  3. Prop the boards beside a window on the sunny side and on the shaded side. Exterior colors shift a lot between morning and late afternoon.
  4. View from the street, not up close. Shutters are read at 30 to 60 feet, where colors look darker and less saturated.
  5. Check against the roof and the darkest brick to make sure the shutter relates to at least one of them.
  6. Live with the samples for two or three days, including an overcast day, before committing.

Materials, Paint and Cost Ranges

Once you settle on shutter colors for brick houses like yours, repainting existing shutters is the cheapest refresh. Wood shutters take an exterior acrylic latex primer and topcoat; vinyl shutters need a paint formulated for vinyl, and darker colors on vinyl should be labeled vinyl-safe so they do not absorb too much heat and warp. Composite shutters generally accept standard exterior acrylic after cleaning and light scuffing.

Option Typical cost per pair Notes
DIY repaint $10 to $30 in paint and supplies Remove shutters, clean, prime if needed, two coats
Pro repaint $50 to $150 Often priced per shutter with a minimum
New vinyl shutters $40 to $150 Factory colors, limited sizes
New composite or wood shutters $150 to $600 or more Custom sizes, operable hardware possible

Size matters as much as color. Each shutter should be about half the width of the window opening and the full height of the window, so that, if closed, the pair would cover it. Undersized shutters look tacked on regardless of color.

Safety for Removing and Painting Shutters

Most shutter work happens on a ladder. Set an extension ladder on firm, level ground at roughly a 1-to-4 angle (one foot out for every four feet of height), extend it at least three feet past the landing point, and keep three points of contact. Do not overreach; move the ladder instead. A helper to steady the base and hand up tools makes the job safer. On two-story homes and above, consider hiring a painter with proper staging or a lift.

Brick and fasteners can also be an issue. Shutters on brick are often held with masonry screws or plugs; removing and reinstalling them can crack old mortar. Use the existing holes when possible, and if new holes are needed, drill into mortar joints rather than brick faces. Homes built before 1978 may have lead paint on old wood shutters, so test before sanding and use lead-safe practices if it is present.

Common Mistakes

  • Matching shutters to the brick: low contrast hides the windows.
  • Choosing from a tiny chip indoors: exterior light washes colors out; dark colors look lighter outdoors and bright colors look louder.
  • Ignoring the mortar: gray mortar cools a brick facade; tan mortar warms it.
  • Too many accent colors: keep shutters and door related.
  • Glossy finishes on old shutters: high gloss highlights every dent; satin is more forgiving.

Frequently Asked Questions

What color shutters look best on red brick?

Black, deep green and charcoal are the most reliable shutter colors on red brick. Navy or slate blue works when the brick has cooler purple or gray tones.

Should shutters be darker or lighter than brick?

Either works, but they should contrast clearly. On most red, orange and brown brick, darker shutters look best. Cream shutters can work on dark brown brick.

Do white shutters look good on brick houses?

White shutters can look stark on orange or red brick and often blend into white trim. They work better on dark brown brick or with soft cream instead of bright white.

What shutter color goes with orange brick?

Warm, deep colors suit orange brick best: dark bronze, black-brown, deep olive or warm charcoal. Avoid icy blues and stark white shutters.

Should shutters match the front door?

Matching gives a calm, unified look. A contrasting door can be the one bold accent, as long as it relates to the shutters or the brick.