What is the Best Toilet: Complete Guide for Homeowners

The toilet is the most-used fixture in your house and the one most people ignore until it fails. Asking what is the best toilet is really asking three questions at once — which flushes most reliably, which is most comfortable to sit on, and which won’t clog every other Sunday morning. After installing more than a thousand toilets across remodel and new-construction work, the answer rarely involves the most expensive option. Here’s how to choose smart.

Part of our Bathroom Remodeling & Flooring guide — explore the full guide →

Flush Performance Trumps Brand Loyalty

The single most important spec is the MaP score — Maximum Performance test result measured in grams of solid waste cleared in a single flush. Anything over 800 grams handles real-world use without backups. Premium toilets like the Toto Drake II hit 1,000 grams. Cheap builder-grade models limp along at 350 to 500 grams and clog weekly.

Flush technology matters too. Pressure-assist toilets (Sloan Flushmate, Gerber DF series) blast waste with compressed air and rarely clog, but they’re loud and the cartridges fail every 8 to 10 years. Gravity flush is quieter, simpler to repair, and now competes on power thanks to wider 3-inch flush valves.

Toto Drake II: Best Overall Standard Toilet

The Toto Drake II at $400 to $480 has been my default recommendation for a decade. The G-Max flush system uses a 3-inch valve and a fully glazed 2-1/8 inch trapway that resists clogs. The MaP rating is 1,000 grams. Spare parts are stocked at every plumbing supply house in America.

Comfort height (called “Universal Height” in Toto’s catalog) puts the seat 17-1/4 inches from the floor — about 2 inches taller than a standard toilet. That extra height matters as you age and helps anyone with knee or hip issues. Two-piece construction means a separate tank and bowl, which is easier to carry into the bathroom and through narrow doorways.

Kohler Cimarron: Best Mid-Range Pick

Kohler Cimarron at $300 to $400 wins on value. The Class Five flush system clears 800 grams in MaP testing, comes in comfort or standard height, and parts are available at any Home Depot or Lowe’s. The trapway is glazed and 2-1/8 inches wide, which is the same dimension as the Toto.

The Cimarron uses 1.28 gallons per flush and qualifies for WaterSense rebates in many municipalities — call your water department before installing because some offer $50 to $100 toward the upgrade. Skirted models (Cimarron Skirted) hide the trapway curves for easier cleaning at a $100 premium.

American Standard Champion 4: Best for Heavy Use

If you have a household with multiple kids or you’re outfitting a vacation rental, the American Standard Champion 4 at $350 to $450 is built for abuse. The flush valve is a massive 4 inches — nearly double the typical 2-inch valve — which moves a remarkable amount of water in 1.28 gallons.

The MaP score is 1,000 grams and the trapway resists everything from baby wipes (which still shouldn’t be flushed) to small toys. The downside is that 4-inch valve makes the tank heavier and the flush noticeably louder than a Toto. For a master bathroom that matters less than for a busy guest bath.

Toto Neorest 700H: Best Smart Toilet

If budget is no object, the Toto Neorest 700H at $5,500 to $6,500 is the gold standard. Auto-open lid, integrated bidet with adjustable water temperature, heated seat, automatic deodorizer, and a tornado flush that uses just 0.8 gallons most cycles. It also self-cleans the bowl with electrolyzed water after every flush.

Installation requires a dedicated 120-volt GFCI outlet within 36 inches of the toilet. Plan electrical work into the budget. For a primary bathroom remodel, the Neorest is the kind of upgrade you don’t appreciate until you live with it for a month and then can’t go back.

One-Piece vs Two-Piece Toilets

One-piece toilets like the Kohler Santa Rosa or Toto Carlyle II look cleaner because there’s no seam between tank and bowl. Cleaning is easier — no crevice catches dust and hair. The price premium runs $150 to $300 over equivalent two-piece models.

Two-piece toilets are easier to install in tight spaces. A one-piece can weigh 130 pounds in a single awkward block, while a two-piece breaks into a 60-pound bowl and a 50-pound tank. For second-floor bathrooms reached by narrow stairs, the two-piece is the right call.

Round vs Elongated Bowls

Elongated bowls measure roughly 18-1/2 inches from the seat hinge to the front rim — about 2 inches longer than round bowls. They’re more comfortable for adults. Round bowls fit better in small bathrooms where the door swing or vanity proximity is tight. If your rough-in measurement allows it, choose elongated.

Comfort height (17 inches and taller) versus standard height (15 inches) is the other dimension. ADA-compliant comfort height is the standard in new construction now and worth choosing for any household with anyone over 50 or under 4 feet tall.

Rough-In Distance and Other Install Details

Measure from the finished wall behind the toilet to the center of the closet bolts. Standard rough-in is 12 inches. Older homes sometimes have 10-inch or 14-inch rough-in dimensions, and using the wrong toilet leaves a 2-inch gap behind the tank or pushes the bowl too far forward. Toto, Kohler, and American Standard all sell models in 10-inch and 14-inch rough-in versions — order accordingly.

Replace the wax ring every time you set a toilet. A $4 part. Skipping it for a reused ring is the leading cause of leaks I see on second-day callbacks. Use a no-seep wax ring with a horn for slab-on-grade or any flange that sits below finished floor height.

What is the Best Toilet for Your Specific Situation

For most homes, the Toto Drake II is the answer to what is the best toilet — high MaP score, fair price, universal parts. For families with kids, the Champion 4 handles abuse. For aesthetic-driven master baths, the Cimarron Skirted or a Toto one-piece looks cleaner. For luxury, the Neorest changes how you feel about a room you spend 30 minutes a day in.

Avoid no-name brands sold only at big-box stores under house labels. They flush fine for two years and then the flapper geometry becomes impossible to find. Stick with Toto, Kohler, American Standard, or Gerber. Pay once, install once, forget about it for 25 years.