Mid-tone grays have a habit of shifting color as the light moves, and Benjamin Moore Puritan Gray is a good example. On the chip it looks like a steady, sober gray. On a wall or a clapboard house it can read blue in the morning, a little green next to plants and almost charcoal at dusk. That range is exactly why people like it, and also why it needs testing.
Puritan Gray is color number HC-164 in the brand’s Historical Colors collection, filed under neutrals. The manufacturer calls it a dignified blue-gray and lists an LRV (light reflectance value) of 34.29. That puts it in medium territory: deep enough to give real color and contrast with white trim, light enough that it doesn’t swallow a room the way a charcoal does.
- Benjamin Moore Puritan Gray at a Glance
- Understanding the Undertone
- Best Rooms and Uses for Puritan Gray
- Coordinating Trim and Accent Colors
- Puritan Gray vs Rockport Gray and Edgecomb Gray
- Choosing a Sheen and Pairing With Floors
- Tools and Materials
- How to Test and Apply Puritan Gray
- Troubleshooting
- Cost Considerations
- When to Call a Pro
- Frequently Asked Questions
It suits exteriors on traditional and coastal homes, home offices, dining rooms, cabinetry and accent walls. In a small, dim room it can feel heavy, so pair it with good light or use it on lower cabinets and doors rather than every wall.
Benjamin Moore Puritan Gray at a Glance
The specs in the table come from the manufacturer’s color page. Undertone notes start from the maker’s description of a blue-gray.
| Spec | Value | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Color name | Puritan Gray | Order by name and number |
| Color number | HC-164 | HC marks the Historical Colors collection |
| Collection | Historical Colors | A traditional palette often used on period homes |
| Color family | Neutral | Grouped with grays and neutrals on the brand’s site |
| LRV | 34.29 | Medium depth; reflects about a third of the light |
| Undertone | Blue-gray with a green lean | Reads cool; can show green beside foliage or warm wood |
| Brand-listed coordinates | Kendall Charcoal HC-166, Ballet White OC-9, Pale Smoke 1584, White Heron OC-57 | Colors the maker suggests pairing with it |
The maker lists Gray Cardigan 1600 (LRV 34.74), Gibraltar Cliffs 1587 (31.77), Greyhound 1579 (37.93) and Cobblestone Path 1606 (37.29) as similar colors, which makes them useful side-by-side samples.
Understanding the Undertone
The maker’s own description, a blue-gray, is the best starting point. Its hex value (#979F9B) has green slightly ahead of red and blue, so in real rooms it can read cool blue-gray or faintly green at different times.
- North light: the blue side shows most. Puritan Gray looks cooler and a little moody.
- South and west light: warm sun pulls out the green, giving a soft gray-green or sage-adjacent look.
- Outdoors: bright daylight lightens it a step and emphasizes the blue, especially on north-facing elevations.
- Warm bulbs (2700K to 3000K): the color settles into a calmer, more neutral gray.
If you love the depth but find the green distracting, test it beside your floors, counters and trim before committing.
Best Rooms and Uses for Puritan Gray
Exterior Siding and Doors
Puritan Gray is a classic choice on clapboard and shingle siding, where it gives a weathered coastal look. With bright white trim, black or charcoal shutters, and a deeper front door, it looks finished and traditional. Outdoors, the color will read lighter than on the chip, so many homeowners find a mid-tone like this lands where they wanted.
Kitchen Cabinets and Islands
On lower cabinets or an island, Puritan Gray adds color without the formality of navy or the weight of charcoal. It pairs well with white quartz, marble-look counters and brushed brass or nickel hardware.
Home Offices, Dens and Dining Rooms
These rooms benefit from enclosing, cozy color. Puritan Gray walls with white trim feel tailored, and it works with walnut or oak furniture as long as the room gets reasonable light.
Bedrooms
In a bedroom with good daylight, it creates a calm, grounded mood. In a small or north-facing room, try it on one wall or the headboard wall first.
Coordinating Trim and Accent Colors
The manufacturer suggests four companions on the color page:
- White Heron OC-57: a white from the Off-White Collection, a natural pick for trim and ceilings.
- Ballet White OC-9: another off-white option, suggested for trim or adjoining walls.
- Pale Smoke 1584: a companion from the Classics collection for nearby rooms or hallways, keeping the palette connected.
- Kendall Charcoal HC-166: a deeper Historical Colors gray for doors, shutters or an accent wall.
Beyond those, clean whites keep Puritan Gray crisp, while creamier whites make it feel softer and more traditional. Brass hardware warms it up; black hardware sharpens it.
Puritan Gray vs Rockport Gray and Edgecomb Gray
All three are Historical Colors grays, but they play very different roles. LRVs are from each manufacturer page.
| Color | Number | LRV | How it reads |
|---|---|---|---|
| Puritan Gray | HC-164 | 34.29 | Cool blue-gray with a green lean |
| Rockport Gray | HC-105 | 36.61 | Rich medium gray; warmer, more earthy |
| Edgecomb Gray | HC-173 | 63.09 | Light, warm greige |
Puritan Gray vs Rockport Gray: they are close in depth, with Rockport Gray a touch lighter by LRV. The difference is temperature: Rockport Gray is described by the maker as a rich medium gray and tends to read warmer and earthier, which suits brick, stone and brown roofs. Puritan Gray is cooler, better with white trim and blue-gray roofs.
Puritan Gray vs Edgecomb Gray: Edgecomb Gray is much lighter and warmer, a go-to neutral greige for walls. The two can work together: Edgecomb Gray on main living walls, Puritan Gray on cabinets, an island or a front door for contrast.
Choosing a Sheen and Pairing With Floors
On interior walls, a matte or eggshell finish keeps Puritan Gray looking soft and chalky, which flatters its historic character and hides minor wall flaws. In kitchens, mudrooms and bathrooms, satin is easier to wipe. For cabinets, doors and trim painted in this color, semi-gloss or a cabinet-grade satin gives the durability those surfaces need. Higher sheens bounce more light, so expect the same color to look a little lighter and bluer on glossy cabinet doors than on matte walls beside them.
Floors make a real difference with a mid-tone like this. White oak, natural maple and light gray luxury vinyl plank let Puritan Gray stay cool and crisp. Medium brown woods give a warm, classic contrast that suits libraries and dining rooms. Very orange or red-toned floors can pull out the green in the gray, which some people like and others don’t, so place a large sample right beside the floor before committing. Patterned tile with black, white and gray tones looks especially good in bathrooms painted this color, and natural stone with gray veining is an easy partner on kitchen counters and backsplashes.
Tools and Materials
- Sample pots or large peel-and-stick samples
- Paint roller and tray kit (3/8 inch nap for smooth interior walls; thicker nap for textured siding)
- Angled sash brush for cutting in
- Gray-tinted primer, which helps a mid-tone cover evenly
- Painter’s tape, drop cloths, spackle and sanding sponges
- For cabinets: degreaser, bonding primer and a fine foam roller
How to Test and Apply Puritan Gray
- Sample on large boards. Two coats on boards at least 12 by 12 inches give a true read.
- Test beside fixed finishes. Hold samples next to floors, counters, roofing and brick, not just white walls.
- Check over two or three days. Look in morning, midday and evening light, and with lamps on.
- Prep thoroughly. Clean, patch, sand and spot-prime. On cabinets, degrease and scuff before bonding primer.
- Prime when changing color a lot. Going from white or a very dark color benefits from a tinted primer.
- Apply two finish coats. Keep a wet edge and roll full wall heights to avoid lap marks.
Troubleshooting
- Looks too green: warm light or nearby foliage. Use cooler bulbs, or move toward a more neutral gray.
- Looks too blue or cold: north light or very white trim. Try a creamier trim white or warmer bulbs.
- Feels too dark: the room lacks light. Use it on lower cabinets or one wall, and keep ceilings white.
- Uneven, streaky finish: needs another coat or tinted primer, and a consistent roller nap.
Cost Considerations
Premium interior paint usually runs from around 50 to 100 dollars per gallon, and exterior lines often sit at the upper end of that range or higher. A gallon covers roughly 350 to 400 square feet per coat on smooth surfaces. Professional exterior painting of an average house often costs several thousand dollars, depending on size, height, siding condition and region. Cabinet painting by a pro commonly runs a few thousand dollars for a typical kitchen.
When to Call a Pro
Hire a painter for two-story exteriors, high gables and anything requiring extension ladders or scaffolding, and for sprayed cabinet finishes. On homes built before 1978, test old paint for lead before scraping or sanding, and use a certified lead-safe contractor if it comes back positive.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the LRV of Benjamin Moore Puritan Gray?
The manufacturer’s US color page lists Puritan Gray HC-164 at an LRV of 34.29, a medium-depth gray.
Is Puritan Gray blue or green?
The maker calls it a blue-gray. In warm light or near greenery, many people also see a green lean, so test it in your space.
Is Puritan Gray good for exterior siding?
Yes. It is a popular exterior gray, especially with white trim and dark shutters, and reads a little lighter in full sun than on the chip.
What trim color goes with Puritan Gray?
The maker suggests White Heron OC-57 and Ballet White OC-9 among its coordinates. Clean whites give crisp contrast; creamier whites feel softer.
Is Puritan Gray darker than Rockport Gray?
Slightly. Puritan Gray has an LRV of 34.29 and Rockport Gray 36.61, but the bigger difference is that Rockport Gray reads warmer.