Home Improvement

Sherwin Williams Black Paint Colors: Best Blacks Compared

Sherwin Williams Black Paint Colors: Best Blacks Compared

Black paint looks simple until you put three chips side by side and realize one leans blue, one leans brown and one looks almost charcoal. Sherwin williams black paint colors cover that whole spread, from near-pure neutral blacks to softened charcoals that read black only in low light. The right pick depends on what you’re painting, the light it gets, and whether the surrounding colors are warm or cool.

For a clean, neutral black on a front door, trim or cabinets, Tricorn Black (SW 6258) is the most common starting point. Caviar (SW 6990) and Black Magic (SW 6991) are close neighbors with a slightly softer feel. Inkwell (SW 6992) and Black of Night (SW 6993) lean blue. Iron Ore (SW 7069) is a soft charcoal for exteriors and walls where pure black feels too heavy, and Black Fox (SW 7020) brings a warm brown-black look.

Check the current color page and a physical sample before buying.

Sherwin Williams Black Paint Colors Compared

LRV (light reflectance value) for blacks sits in a narrow band near zero, so a difference of two or three points is clearly visible. Every color here is listed by Sherwin-Williams for interior and exterior use.

Color SW number LRV Undertone Typical use
Tricorn Black SW 6258 2.8 Neutral, a hair cool Front doors, trim, cabinets, window frames
Caviar SW 6990 3.0 Soft neutral Accent walls, doors, furniture
Black Magic SW 6991 3.1 Soft neutral Doors, interior accents, built-ins
Inkwell SW 6992 3.6 Cool, blue-leaning Cabinets, dark rooms, exterior trim
Black of Night SW 6993 3.6 Cool, blue-leaning Libraries, dens, front doors
Greenblack SW 6994 4.1 Cool with a green-gray hint Exteriors, shutters, cabinetry
Iron Ore SW 7069 5.6 Soft charcoal, neutral Siding, walls, exterior trim
Black Fox SW 7020 6.7 Warm, brown-black Warm exteriors, wood-heavy rooms

Undertone notes reflect each color’s published RGB values and how it typically reads on a surface. Lighting, sheen and nearby colors all shift what you see.

Neutral Blacks: Tricorn Black, Caviar and Black Magic

Tricorn Black (SW 6258)

At an LRV of about 2.8, Tricorn Black is the darkest color on this list and the closest to a true neutral black. It reads crisp against bright white trim and works on almost any front door. Because it carries so little undertone, it pairs with warm and cool palettes alike, which is why designers reach for it on window frames, interior doors and stair railings.

Caviar (SW 6990) and Black Magic (SW 6991)

Caviar (about 3.0) and Black Magic (about 3.1) sit just a whisker lighter. On a large wall, that small step softens the black so it feels less stark. Some people see a faint warmth in Caviar next to Tricorn Black. Both work well in a dining room, an office or a bedroom accent wall where you want drama without a harsh edge.

Cool and Warm Blacks: Inkwell, Black of Night, Greenblack and Black Fox

Cool blacks have a noticeable blue or green bias. Inkwell (about 3.6) and Black of Night (about 3.6) both lean blue, which reads as a deep navy-black in daylight and pairs beautifully with brass hardware and white oak. Greenblack (about 4.1) adds a muted green-gray cast that suits historic exteriors, shutters and cabinetry surrounded by greenery.

Black Fox (about 6.7) is the warm option. It shows brown undertones, which makes it a natural fit next to cedar, brick, stone and warm wood floors. It also softens a modern farmhouse exterior that would feel too severe in a neutral black.

Iron Ore: The Charcoal That Reads Black

Iron Ore (SW 7069) sits at about 5.6, so it is technically a very dark charcoal rather than a black. Outdoors, in bright sun, it often reads soft black, which is why it shows up on siding, garage doors and exterior trim. Indoors, it is a gentler option for whole walls, especially where a pure black would swallow the light. If you are torn between Iron Ore and Tricorn Black for an exterior, sample both on the actual siding; the gap is obvious in shade.

Pairing Black With Trim, Hardware and Floors

Black works hardest when the colors around it are chosen on purpose. On walls, a soft white trim keeps a black room from feeling closed in, while painting trim the same black (often a step glossier) creates a wrapped, moody look that is popular in dens and powder rooms. On exteriors, black window frames and doors read sharpest against white, cream or light gray siding.

  • Hardware: Brass and gold glow against blue-leaning blacks like Inkwell; brushed nickel and chrome suit neutral blacks like Tricorn Black.
  • Floors: Warm oak and walnut pair well with Black Fox or Caviar; gray or whitewashed floors pair with cooler blacks.
  • Countertops: White quartz and marble-look surfaces make black cabinets pop; butcher block softens them.
  • Brick and stone: Warm brick usually wants a warm or neutral black rather than a blue-black.

Before choosing among sherwin williams black paint colors for a whole room, paint a large sample board and look at it next to your floor and trim at night. Dark colors change more under artificial light than pale ones, and a black that looks neutral at noon can turn noticeably blue or brown under warm bulbs.

Looking to buy Sherwin Williams Black Paint Colors? Compare top-rated options.
Shop on Amazon →Browse Our Shop
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Tools and Materials

  • Peel-and-stick paint swatches or large sample boards
  • A gray-tinted or deep-base primer recommended for dark colors
  • High-quality microfiber roller covers and a 2 to 2.5 inch angled sash brush
  • Painter’s tape, drop cloths, sanding sponge and tack cloth
  • Exterior-rated paint for doors and siding; a hard-curing enamel for cabinets and trim
  • Good raking light (a work light held at a low angle) to spot holidays and lap marks

How to Paint With Black in Six Steps

  1. Choose the sheen. Matte and flat hide wall flaws but scuff easily. Satin is a good balance for walls. Semi-gloss or gloss works for doors, trim and cabinets but shows every dent.
  2. Prep thoroughly. Black magnifies flaws. Fill dents, sand smooth and wipe away dust.
  3. Prime with a tinted primer. A dark-tinted primer reduces the number of finish coats needed.
  4. Cut in and roll in sections. Keep a wet edge and work wall by wall to avoid lap marks.
  5. Apply two full coats. Most dark colors need at least two coats for even depth; deep reds and blacks sometimes need three.
  6. Let it cure. Dry to the touch isn’t cured. Treat doors and cabinets gently for the cure time on the label.

Troubleshooting Black Paint

Streaks or lap marks. Usually from rolling over partly dry paint. Keep a wet edge, use a quality roller cover and avoid overworking.

Patchy sheen. Uneven porosity under the paint. Spot-prime patches and repairs before the finish coat.

Looks blue or brown. That is undertone. Swap to a more neutral black like Tricorn Black or move to one that matches the room.

Front door gets hot or sticky. Dark colors absorb heat. Check that the door and storm door manufacturers allow dark colors, since some warranties limit them behind glass storm doors.

Scuffs on flat walls. Repaint high-traffic areas in a scrubbable matte or satin.

Cost to Paint With Black

Dark colors don’t usually cost more per gallon, but they may need an extra coat and a tinted primer. Expect a gallon of interior paint to fall roughly in the $30 to $90 range by product line. A front door is a small DIY project at well under $100 in materials. Professional painting for an accent wall or door commonly runs from about $100 to a few hundred dollars, and a full exterior in a dark color will be priced on house size, height and prep.

When to Call a Pro

Hire a painter for exterior siding above one story, cabinet refinishing that calls for spraying, and any job where a flawless finish matters more than savings. In homes built before 1978, test existing paint for lead before sanding or scraping and use lead-safe work practices or a certified contractor if lead is present.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the darkest Sherwin-Williams black?

Among the common blacks, Tricorn Black (SW 6258) has the lowest LRV at about 2.8, so it is the darkest and closest to a neutral true black.

Is Tricorn Black warm or cool?

It is close to neutral, with a very faint cool lean. That makes it easy to pair with both warm and cool palettes.

What is the difference between Iron Ore and Tricorn Black?

Iron Ore (LRV about 5.6) is a soft charcoal, while Tricorn Black (about 2.8) is a deeper true black. Iron Ore looks softer in shade and on large surfaces.

Which Sherwin-Williams black is best for a front door?

Tricorn Black is a popular pick for its crisp, neutral look. Inkwell or Black of Night suit homes with cool palettes, and Black Fox suits warm brick or stone.

Which sheen is best for black paint?

Satin for walls, and semi-gloss or gloss for doors, trim and cabinets. Flat and matte hide flaws but mark more easily.

Can these blacks be used outdoors?

Sherwin-Williams lists all of them for interior and exterior use. Use an exterior-grade product and check door and siding warranties for dark color limits.