Home Improvement

Benjamin Moore Light Gray Paint Colors Compared

Benjamin Moore Light Gray Paint Colors Compared

Most people who pick a light gray off a tiny chip end up with a wall that looks either blue or beige once it dries. Choosing among benjamin moore light gray paint colors gets much easier when you sort them by two numbers the maker publishes for every shade: the color code and the light reflectance value (LRV). LRV runs from 0 (absorbs all light) to 100 (reflects all light), so it tells you how light a gray will read before you open a can.

The short answer: if you want a gray that barely reads as gray, look at Ice Mist, Misty Gray and Paper White, which sit in the mid 70s to high 80s for LRV. For a gray that is clearly gray but still light, Ice Cube Silver, Classic Gray, Balboa Mist and Gray Owl land in the 60s and low 70s. Stonington Gray and Revere Pewter are the deeper end of “light” in the mid to high 50s. Undertone decides the rest: cool, blue-leaning grays brighten south-facing rooms, while softer, warmer grays keep north light from feeling chilly.

Every LRV and code in this comparison was checked against the color pages on the Benjamin Moore website. Retailer sites and screens round or shift these numbers, so treat the maker’s page as the reference and always confirm on a physical sample.

Benjamin Moore Light Gray Paint Colors at a Glance

The table sorts the shades from lightest to deepest by LRV. Undertone notes paraphrase how Benjamin Moore describes each color; where the maker does not name an undertone, that is stated plainly.

Color Code LRV Undertone / character Best rooms
Ice Mist 2123-70 88.84 Clean white with bright blue undertones Trim, ceilings, small dim baths
Misty Gray 2124-60 80.58 Pale blue-gray, softly cool Bedrooms, south-facing living rooms
Paper White OC-55 74.41 White with a touch of blue-gray Whole-house walls, kitchens
Ice Cube Silver 2121-50 73.74 Light gray with a crisp blue cast Bathrooms, modern kitchens
Classic Gray OC-23 73.67 Ultra-light gray that can work as an off-white (undertone not stated by maker) Open plans, hallways
Balboa Mist OC-27 65.53 Pale gray with a slightly warm cast North-facing rooms, living areas
Gray Owl OC-52 64.51 Light gray with a cool, crisp cast Offices, bedrooms, cabinets
Stonington Gray HC-170 59.36 Silvery gray, relatively neutral Living rooms, exteriors, accent walls
Revere Pewter HC-172 55.05 Bridges warm and cool tones Traditional homes, open plans with wood

One quirk worth knowing: on the Benjamin Moore site, Ice Mist, Misty Gray, Paper White, Classic Gray, Balboa Mist and Gray Owl are filed under the white color family, not gray or neutral. That classification is a clue to how they behave on a wall. In a bright room they lean toward white; in dim light the gray comes forward.

How to Read LRV and Undertone Before You Buy

LRV is the most useful single number for a light gray. Above roughly 75, a gray will read as an off-white in most daylight. Between about 60 and 75, it reads as a clear but airy gray. In the 50s, you get a visible, grounded gray that still counts as light but will darken noticeably in a room with one small window.

Undertone is the second filter. Gray paint is rarely pure; most shades carry a hint of blue, green, violet or beige. Cool grays such as Misty Gray, Ice Cube Silver and Gray Owl can look icy in north light, which is already blue. Warmer or balanced grays such as Balboa Mist and Revere Pewter hold up better there. South- and west-facing rooms get warm, yellow light, which neutralizes a blue-leaning gray nicely.

Flooring and fixed finishes matter as much as the window. Orange-toned oak floors can make a cool gray look bluer by contrast, while gray or white tile pulls a warm gray toward beige. Hold a sample against the floor, the countertop and the trim before committing.

The Lightest Grays: Ice Mist, Misty Gray and Paper White

Ice Mist (2123-70)

With an LRV of 88.84, Ice Mist is close to a true white. Benjamin Moore describes it as a clean white lit by bright blue undertones. On walls it reads as a crisp, cool white with a whisper of gray in shadowed corners. It works well on ceilings, as a trim color next to cool grays, and in small interior bathrooms where you want every bit of reflected light. It can feel stark beside warm wood, so test it against your floors.

Misty Gray (2124-60)

Misty Gray sits at 80.58 and is described by the maker as a vaporous pale blue-gray with a softly cool cast. It is the shade to try if you want the faintest suggestion of gray. In a south-facing bedroom it reads as a calm, airy off-white. In a north-facing room it shows more of its blue side, which some people like and others find cold.

Paper White (OC-55)

Despite the name, Paper White carries a touch of blue-gray and lands at 74.41. It is a popular whole-house wall color for people who want something softer than a bright white without committing to a visible gray. Pair it with a brighter white on trim so the walls do not look dingy by comparison.

Classic Light Grays: Ice Cube Silver, Classic Gray, Balboa Mist and Gray Owl

Ice Cube Silver (2121-50)

You will see this one written as both Ice Cube Silver and Iced Cube Silver; both names point to the same code, 2121-50. The current US color page calls it Ice Cube Silver, lists an LRV of 73.74 and describes a light gray with a crisp blue cast. It suits bathrooms with white tile and chrome fixtures and kitchens with white or gray cabinets. In rooms with lots of warm wood it may look noticeably blue.

Classic Gray (OC-23)

Classic Gray has an LRV of 73.67, nearly identical to Ice Cube Silver, but Benjamin Moore positions it as an ultra-light gray that can also function as an off-white. The maker does not name an undertone on its color page, so judge it on a sample in your own light. It is a common choice for open floor plans because it shifts gently from room to room instead of reading as a strong color.

Balboa Mist (OC-27)

At 65.53, Balboa Mist is a pale gray with a slightly warm cast, according to the maker. That warmth makes it one of the better light grays for north-facing living rooms and for homes with cream trim, oak floors or brass hardware. It looks gray without looking cold.

Gray Owl (OC-52)

Gray Owl is described as a use-anywhere light gray with a cool, crisp cast and has an LRV of 64.51. It reads more clearly gray than Balboa Mist and leans cooler. It is a good fit for home offices, bedrooms and painted cabinetry in kitchens with white counters. In rooms with very little daylight, cool grays like this one can look deeper and flatter than the chip suggests, so sample it on two walls.

Looking to buy Benjamin Moore Light Gray Paint Colors Compared? Compare top-rated options.
Shop on Amazon →Browse Our Shop
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Deeper Light Grays: Stonington Gray and Revere Pewter

Once LRV drops into the 50s, you are at the deep end of the light gray range. These shades are good for living rooms where you want the walls to read as a color, for accent walls next to a paler gray, and for exteriors where a lighter gray can wash out in full sun.

Stonington Gray (HC-170) has an LRV of 59.36 and is described as an all-purpose silvery gray with relatively neutral undertones. It is one of the more balanced options here, which makes it easy to pair with both white and black trim.

Revere Pewter (HC-172) comes in at 55.05 and is described by the maker as an iconic neutral that bridges warm and cool tones. In practice it often reads as a greige, especially next to warm wood. It is a strong choice for traditional homes and for open plans where the walls need to work with both a wood kitchen and gray upholstery.

For reference, the next step deeper is Coventry Gray (HC-169) at 48.18, which Benjamin Moore calls a medium gray. If Revere Pewter or Stonington Gray look too light on your sample, that is the direction to go.

How to Test Benjamin Moore Light Gray Paint Colors at Home

Light grays shift more than any other color family because small undertones get magnified across a whole wall. A methodical test takes about a week and saves you from repainting.

  1. Shortlist three shades. Pick by LRV range first, then undertone. For example, one cool option, one warm option and one balanced option in the same LRV band.
  2. Use large samples. Peel-and-stick paint sample swatches or painted sample boards at least 12 by 12 inches show the color far more accurately than a chip. They also let you move the sample without painting the wall.
  3. Place samples on every wall. Put one on the window wall, one on the wall opposite and one near the floor next to trim and flooring.
  4. Check at three times of day. Look in morning light, at midday and at night under your actual bulbs. Warm white bulbs (around 2700K) push grays warmer; cooler bulbs (4000K and up) push them bluer.
  5. Compare against white. Hold a sheet of plain white printer paper next to each sample. The undertone becomes obvious by contrast.
  6. Decide on sheen. Flat and matte finishes hide wall flaws and look slightly deeper. Eggshell is the usual choice for living areas, and satin or semi-gloss suits baths, kitchens and trim.

Troubleshooting Common Light Gray Problems

The wall looks blue. Cool grays in north light or under cool bulbs do this. Switch to a warmer gray such as Balboa Mist or Revere Pewter, or change bulbs to a warmer color temperature.

The wall looks beige or muddy. Warm grays next to yellow-toned oak or cream trim can drift toward beige. Try a more neutral shade such as Stonington Gray, or a cooler one such as Gray Owl.

The gray looks almost white. High-LRV shades in a bright room wash out. Drop roughly 10 points of LRV, for example from Misty Gray to Gray Owl.

The gray looks too dark in a small room. A gray in the 50s can feel heavy in a room with one window. Move up to the 70s range with Classic Gray or Paper White.

The color looks patchy. Light grays over darker or glossy old paint often need primer and two finish coats. Patchy sheen usually means the second coat went on too thin or the wall was not primed after patching.

Cost and When to Hire a Painter

Premium interior paint typically runs in a mid to upper range per gallon, and one gallon covers roughly 350 to 400 square feet per coat on smooth, primed drywall. A 12 by 14 foot bedroom with 8 foot ceilings usually needs about 2 gallons for two coats on the walls. Add sample swatches, a roller and tray kit, tape and drop cloths, and a DIY room usually lands in the low hundreds of dollars.

Professional painters generally charge by the room or by square foot, and a standard bedroom often falls in the several hundred dollar range, more with ceilings, trim or major drywall repair. It makes sense to hire a pro for tall stairwells and two-story foyers (ladder and scaffold work), for whole-house repaints on a deadline and for exterior work above the first floor. If your home was built before 1978, have old paint tested for lead before sanding or scraping.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the lightest Benjamin Moore light gray?

Of the shades compared here, Ice Mist (2123-70) has the highest LRV at 88.84, followed by Misty Gray (2124-60) at 80.58. Both read as very soft, cool off-whites on most walls, with gray showing mainly in shadow.

Is Ice Cube Silver the same as Iced Cube Silver?

Yes. Both names refer to Benjamin Moore color 2121-50. The current US color page uses Ice Cube Silver and lists an LRV of 73.74 with a crisp blue cast.

Which Benjamin Moore light gray is warm?

Balboa Mist (OC-27) is described by the maker as a pale gray with a slightly warm cast. Revere Pewter (HC-172) bridges warm and cool tones and often reads as a greige next to wood.

What LRV should a light gray have?

For walls that read as clearly light, aim for an LRV between about 55 and 75. Above 75 a gray tends to look like an off-white, and below the mid 50s it starts reading as a medium gray.

Is Misty Gray a gray or a white?

Benjamin Moore files Misty Gray under its white color family but describes it as a pale blue-gray. On a wall it reads as an off-white in bright rooms and shows more gray in low light.

Do I need primer for a light gray over a dark color?

Yes. Going from a dark or saturated color to a light gray usually needs a tinted primer plus two finish coats to avoid the old color showing through.