Repainting the outside of a house is one of the few projects where the paint you choose matters as much as the labor. Skimp on the coating and you could be back on a ladder in three years. Benjamin Moore Regal Select Exterior paint sits in the brand’s mid-to-upper tier, above the budget lines but below the premium Aura Exterior, and for most homeowners it hits the sweet spot of durability, price, and workability. This guide covers what you actually get, how it applies, and whether it is the right call for your siding.
Part of our Paint & Walls guide — explore the full guide →
- Where Regal Select Fits in the Lineup
- Coverage and How Much You Need
- Sheen Options and Where to Use Them
- Surface Prep: Where the Job Is Won
- Application Tips for a Smooth Finish
- Durability and What to Expect Over Time
- Cost and Value
- Is Regal Select Right for You?
- How It Performs on Different Surfaces
- Tools and Techniques for a Pro Finish
- Common Questions
Where Regal Select Fits in the Lineup
Benjamin Moore stacks its exterior paints roughly like this: Aura Exterior at the top, Regal Select Exterior in the upper-middle, and lines like Ben and standard offerings below. Regal Select uses a 100 percent acrylic latex formula engineered to flex with siding as it expands and contracts through temperature swings, which is what prevents the cracking and peeling that plague cheaper paints.
You are paying for resin quality and pigment load. That translates to better hide, richer color, and a film that resists fading, mildew, and dirt pickup far longer than economy paint. For a home you plan to keep, the math usually favors spending here rather than repainting sooner.
Coverage and How Much You Need
Regal Select Exterior covers roughly 350 to 400 square feet per gallon on a smooth, primed surface. Rough or porous surfaces like fiber cement, stucco, or bare wood drink more, so plan closer to 250 to 300 square feet per gallon there.
To estimate, measure the perimeter of your house, multiply by the wall height, and subtract windows and doors. A typical 1,800-square-foot two-story home has roughly 1,500 to 2,000 square feet of paintable wall. For two coats, most homes need 8 to 12 gallons of body color plus a gallon or two for trim. Always buy a little extra from the same tint batch so touch-ups match perfectly.
Sheen Options and Where to Use Them
Choosing the right sheen matters as much as the color because gloss level affects both looks and durability:
- Flat/Matte: Hides surface imperfections and old patch work best. Ideal for older siding and stucco, but harder to scrub clean.
- Low Lustre (satin): The most popular body choice. Slight sheen, easy to clean, resists mildew, and looks good on lap siding and shingles.
- Soft Gloss: Reserved for trim, doors, shutters, and railings where you want a crisp, wipeable finish that pops against the body color.
A common approach is Low Lustre on the field and Soft Gloss on the trim. That contrast is what gives a repaint that clean, professional look.
Surface Prep: Where the Job Is Won
No paint, however good, bonds to a dirty or flaking surface. Budget the majority of your project time for prep, not painting. The sequence that works:
- Wash the siding with a pressure washer or a scrub-and-hose approach, treating any mildew with an appropriate cleaner.
- Scrape all loose and peeling paint back to a sound edge, then sand the transitions smooth.
- Prime bare wood, rust spots, and heavy stains with the matching Benjamin Moore exterior primer. Regal Select is self-priming over previously painted, sound surfaces, but bare substrate needs a dedicated primer.
- Caulk gaps around trim, windows, and joints with a paintable exterior acrylic caulk.
- Let everything dry fully before the first coat.
Application Tips for a Smooth Finish
Regal Select brushes and rolls well and levels out to hide stroke marks better than budget paint. Apply it when temperatures sit roughly between 40 and 90 degrees Fahrenheit, and avoid painting in direct hot sun, which flashes the surface and leaves lap marks. Early morning after any dew has dried, or late afternoon, gives you a workable window.
Use a quality 2.5-inch angled sash brush for cutting in and a 3/8-inch nap roller for smooth siding, stepping up to a 1/2-inch nap for textured surfaces. Maintain a wet edge and work in manageable sections so each pass blends. Two coats is the standard recommendation, and it genuinely matters for color depth and longevity. The paint dries to the touch in about an hour and can typically be recoated in four hours, though cool or humid days stretch that.
Durability and What to Expect Over Time
Applied over proper prep, Regal Select Exterior commonly holds up 8 to 12 years before needing a full repaint, with south- and west-facing walls fading first because they take the most sun. Its mildew-resistant formula is a real advantage in humid climates, and the acrylic film shrugs off dirt so a yearly rinse keeps colors looking fresh.
The most common cause of early failure is not the paint, it is skipped prep or painting over damp wood. Do the groundwork and this line delivers on its promise.
Cost and Value
Expect to pay roughly $55 to $75 per gallon depending on sheen and your region, with Benjamin Moore’s periodic sales knocking that down. Compared with Aura Exterior at $80-plus per gallon, Regal Select saves meaningful money on a whole-house job while still delivering strong performance. Against big-box premium lines, it competes closely and many painters prefer its workability.
For a full-house exterior with two coats, materials alone often land between $600 and $1,000. That is a fraction of what you save by not repainting for a decade.
Is Regal Select Right for You?
Choose it if you want a long-lasting, low-maintenance finish and are willing to do the prep. Step up to Aura only if you need maximum hide in deep or difficult colors, or the absolute longest lifespan. Step down to Ben only for outbuildings or short-term rentals where longevity matters less.
For the typical homeowner repainting a home they intend to keep, Benjamin Moore Regal Select Exterior paint is a dependable, high-value choice. Pair it with thorough prep and the correct sheen for each surface, and you will get a durable, good-looking result that stands up to the weather for years.
How It Performs on Different Surfaces
Regal Select adapts to most common exterior substrates, but each has quirks worth knowing. On wood clapboard and cedar it flexes with the seasonal movement of the boards and resists the cracking that stiffer paints show at the laps. Over fiber cement siding, which is factory-primed, it bonds well and covers the slightly textured surface in two coats. On stucco and masonry, prime any chalky or bare areas first and expect higher consumption because the porous surface drinks paint.
For previously painted metal like railings and downspouts, spot-prime bare or rusted areas with the appropriate primer before topcoating. Matching the primer to the substrate is what unlocks the paint’s full lifespan, no acrylic topcoat performs to spec over an unprimed problem surface.
Tools and Techniques for a Pro Finish
Beyond brush and roller choice, a few habits separate an amateur job from a clean one. Box your paint, combine all the gallons of one color into a single large container, so any slight tint variation between cans blends into one consistent shade across the whole house. Cut in the trim edges and corners just ahead of rolling each section so the brushed and rolled areas melt together while both are wet.
If you spray, back-roll or back-brush the first coat into the surface to work paint into the texture and improve adhesion, then spray the second coat for an even finish. Keep a wet rag handy for immediate cleanup of drips on windows and hardware, since dried acrylic is far harder to remove.
Common Questions
Do I need a primer with Regal Select? Not over sound, previously painted surfaces, where it is self-priming. Bare wood, bare masonry, rust, and heavy stains do need the matching primer first.
How soon can it get wet? Give it as much dry time as the label specifies and avoid painting when rain is expected within several hours, moisture on uncured paint causes streaking and adhesion problems.
Is it worth the price over cheaper lines? For a home you plan to keep, yes. The longer repaint cycle and better fade and mildew resistance more than offset the higher per-gallon cost.