Home Improvement

Kohler Cast Iron Tub Lines: Sizes, Weight & Styles Compared

Kohler Cast Iron Tub Lines: Sizes, Weight & Styles Compared

Most people shopping for a kohler cast iron tub assume the lines differ mainly in looks. They don’t. Dry weight across the lineup runs from about 310 lbs to 430 lbs, water capacity ranges from 33 to 69 gallons, and the drain side alone can make a tub useless for your bathroom if you order the wrong one.

For a standard 5-foot alcove, the Villager, Bellwether and Mendota lines do the job. If you have the floor space and the structure for a statement piece, look at the freestanding Artifacts or Birthday Bath. Iron Works Historic shows up on older spec lists, but it now looks discontinued. Kohler notes those dimensions are nominal, so confirm against the current sheet for your exact model number before you order.

Here is how the lines compare, what each weighs when filled, and what installation really involves.

Kohler Cast Iron Tub Lines at a Glance

This kohler cast iron tub comparison uses one representative model number from each line. All of them are enameled cast iron with Kohler’s Safeguard slip-resistant bottom and integral lumbar support, and all carry the KOHLER Enameled Cast Iron Bath and Shower Base Lifetime Limited Warranty. Read the warranty page for what that actually covers.

Line (model) Size L x W Type / drain Dry weight Water capacity Price tier
Villager (K-714) 60″ x 34-1/4″, 14″ high Alcove, right drain 330 lbs 33 gal Entry
Villager (K-716) 60″ x 30-1/4″, 14″ high Alcove, right drain 316 lbs 33 gal Entry
Bellwether (K-837 / K-838) 60″ x 30-1/4″, 14″ apron Alcove, left or right drain 310 lbs 32.6 gal Entry to mid
Bellwether (K-875) 60″ x 32″, 15″ apron Alcove, left drain 327 lbs 44 gal Mid
Mendota (K-505) 60″ x 32″, 16-1/4″ high Alcove, left drain 351 lbs 45 gal Mid
Iron Works Historic (K-710-W) 66″ x 36″ Freestanding, reversible drain 350 lbs 64 gal Premium (appears discontinued)
Artifacts (K-21000-W) 66-1/8″ x 32-1/2″ Freestanding, center drain 396.2 lbs 69 gal Premium
Birthday Bath (K-100) 72″ x 37-1/2″ Freestanding, reversible drain 430 lbs 50 gal Premium

The price tiers are relative, not quotes. As a general range, a 60-inch cast iron alcove tub from a major maker usually costs somewhere in the low four figures before installation. Freestanding cast iron models tend to run several times that once you add the base or feet and a freestanding filler. Finish color, drain side and regional pricing all move the number.

Alcove Lines: Villager, Bellwether and Mendota

Villager

Kohler’s spec sheet calls the Villager “our most popular bath.” That makes sense, because it is the classic replacement for the 60-inch tub found in millions of older bathrooms. The K-714 measures 60″ x 34-1/4″ x 14″ and the narrower K-716 measures 60″ x 30-1/4″ x 14″. Both hold 33 gallons with a water depth of 8-5/8″. That is a shallow soak, but it suits a combined tub and shower where most of the use is standing. Both models have an integral apron, and both are listed in White and Biscuit.

Bellwether

The Bellwether line has cleaner, squarer lines than the Villager, wide ledges and an integral tiling flange that helps keep water from getting behind the wall. The K-837 (left drain) and K-838 (right drain) are 60″ x 30-1/4″ with a 14″ apron. Each weighs 310 lbs, which makes them the lightest cast iron alcove tubs in this comparison. The K-875 is wider at 60″ x 32″. It has a 15″ apron, 4″ and 3″ ledges, and a deeper 11-5/16″ water depth, which brings capacity up to 44 gallons. Kohler’s spec sheet for the 30-1/4″ Bellwether lists several colors beyond White and Biscuit, including Teal, Fresh Green and Aspen Green. Check whether those colors are currently orderable before you plan a retro bathroom around one.

Mendota

The Mendota K-505 is the deepest alcove tub in this comparison. At 60″ x 32″ x 16-1/4″, it has a 10-7/8″ water depth and holds 45 gallons. It also weighs the most at 351 lbs. On the published sheet it comes in White only. If you want a real soak but your bathroom only fits a standard 5-foot alcove, start with the Mendota. At least one Kohler showroom listing now marks the left-drain white version as discontinued, so confirm it is still orderable before you design around it.

Freestanding Lines: Artifacts, Birthday Bath and Iron Works

The Artifacts K-21000-W is a 66-1/8″ x 32-1/2″ oval with lumbar support at both ends and a center drain. At 69 gallons and a 14-3/8″ water depth, it is the most generous soak in this comparison. Its sheet also lists the highest minimum floor load, at 90 lbs per square foot. It sits on a pedestal base or on separately sold feet, so budget for that part.

The Birthday Bath K-100 is the long one. It measures 72″ x 37-1/2″, holds 50 gallons, and weighs 430 lbs empty. Its reversible drain gives you some flexibility on where the plumbing lands. At 72 inches, a taller bather can stretch out fully, but you need a bathroom with clearance on all sides for cleaning and for the filler.

The Iron Works Historic K-710-W is a 66″ x 36″ oval that sits on ball-and-claw feet sold separately. It weighs 350 lbs and holds 64 gallons. Several sources now list this line as discontinued, so expect limited stock if you find one. If you need a 72-inch Kohler cast iron freestanding tub that is still in the catalog, the Vintage K-700 is a 72″ x 42″ model. It weighs 485 lbs and holds 82 gallons, according to its spec sheet.

What a Filled Cast Iron Tub Actually Weighs

Water weighs about 8.34 lbs per gallon, so a full tub weighs far more than the dry figure on the box. The Villager weighs about 330 lbs empty and roughly 605 lbs filled, before anyone gets in. A Mendota is about 725 lbs filled. A filled Birthday Bath comes close to 850 lbs, and an Artifacts approaches 970 lbs, plus the bather. Freestanding tubs concentrate that weight on a pedestal or four feet instead of spreading it along a full apron and wall ledger.

Kohler prints a “Minimum Floor Load” on each spec sheet for this reason: 51 lbs per square foot for the Villager K-714, 56 for the Mendota and 90 for the Artifacts. Typical residential floors are designed for less than some of those figures, so have a contractor or structural engineer check joist size, span and condition before setting a large freestanding tub on an upper floor or over an old, notched framing bay.

Tools and Materials for Installation

  • Appliance dolly rated for 500+ lbs and at least three or four helpers (stairs need more)
  • Furniture pads or cardboard to protect the enamel and finished floors
  • Level, tape measure, stud finder
  • 2×4 ledger stock and structural screws for alcove tubs (follow the installation guide’s height)
  • Mortar or setting bed if the instructions call for one under the base
  • Bath drain and overflow kit (Kohler lists required drains on many sheets, such as cable or toe-tap drains)
  • Silicone sealant rated for tubs and showers
  • Non-abrasive bathtub cleaner for ongoing care
Looking to buy Kohler Cast Iron Tub Lines? Compare top-rated options.
Shop on Amazon →Browse Our Shop
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Step-by-Step: Choosing and Installing the Right Line

  1. Measure the alcove wall to wall at three heights. Old walls are rarely square. A 60-inch tub needs a true 60-inch opening, and some older alcoves measure a bit tight or wide.
  2. Confirm drain side. Stand facing the tub opening. If the drain sits at your left, you need a left-hand drain. Ordering the wrong side means moving the drain line or returning a 300-plus-pound box.
  3. Compare width to the existing tub. A 30-1/4″ Villager or Bellwether drops into a narrow alcove that a 34-1/4″ Villager or 32″ Mendota won’t fit without wall work.
  4. Check the floor structure. Use the spec sheet’s minimum floor load and the filled weight. Upper-floor and freestanding installs deserve a professional look.
  5. Plan the path in. Measure doors, stair turns and hallway corners. Cast iron cannot flex, so a tub that will not clear a corner will not get to the bathroom.
  6. Set and level. Install the ledger, test fit the tub, connect the drain and overflow, then set it level on the specified base. Do not shim with loose wood scraps alone.
  7. Water test before walls close. Fill it and check every joint for leaks before you tile or set the surround.

Troubleshooting Common Problems

Tub rocks or creaks: the base is not fully supported. Pull it, add the setting bed or mortar the instructions call for, and re-level.

Water pools at the wrong end: the tub is out of level, or the floor sags. Recheck with a level across both directions and correct before finishing.

Chips in the enamel: small chips can be touched up with an enamel repair kit. Larger damage on a new tub should go back to the seller, so inspect it before you install.

Dull or stained surface: cast iron enamel holds up well, but abrasive powders and scouring pads scratch it. Use a non-abrasive bathtub cleaner and a soft cloth, and rinse after use.

Installation Cost Ranges

Labor varies widely by region and access. Expect general ranges along these lines:

  • Swap an old alcove tub for a same-size cast iron alcove model: several hundred to a couple of thousand dollars in labor, depending on demo, tile repair and plumbing changes.
  • Moving the drain to the other side or converting to a freestanding layout: add plumbing labor and, often, subfloor work.
  • Upper-floor freestanding install with structural reinforcement: the highest tier, sometimes rivaling the cost of the tub itself.
  • Haul-away of the old tub: often a separate line item, especially for an old cast iron tub.

When to Call a Licensed Professional

Moving drain or supply lines is plumbing work that typically needs a permit and inspection. A licensed plumber is the safe call if you are unsure. Any question about joist capacity, notched or damaged framing, or a freestanding tub on an upper floor belongs with a contractor or structural engineer. In homes built before the 1980s, old tile adhesive, flooring and joint compound around the tub may contain asbestos. Test before demolition. Finally, moving a cast iron tub is a real injury risk, so hire movers or an installer with equipment if you cannot line up enough help.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a Kohler cast iron tub weigh?

Dry weights on Kohler’s spec sheets range from about 310 lbs for a 60″ x 30-1/4″ Bellwether to 430 lbs for the Birthday Bath. The 72″ x 42″ Vintage weighs 485 lbs. Add about 8.34 lbs per gallon of water for the filled weight.

Which Kohler cast iron alcove tub is the deepest?

Among the standard 60-inch alcove models compared here, the Mendota has the deepest water depth at 10-7/8″ and holds 45 gallons. The 60″ x 32″ Bellwether follows closely with 44 gallons.

Is the Kohler Birthday Bath still available?

The Birthday Bath K-100 has a current specification sheet listing it as a 72″ x 37-1/2″ freestanding bath in White. Availability can change, so confirm with a dealer before planning around it.

Can one person install a cast iron tub?

No. Even the lightest Kohler cast iron alcove model weighs about 310 lbs. Plan on several helpers, a rated dolly and a clear path, or hire an installer.

What is the difference between Villager and Bellwether?

Villager has softer, traditional styling and a 33-gallon capacity. Bellwether has squarer lines, wide ledges and an integral tiling flange, and the 60″ x 32″ version holds 44 gallons. Both fit a standard 5-foot alcove.